Jump to content
The Official RONR Q & A Forums

Greg Goodwiller

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Greg Goodwiller

  • Birthday 10/29/1960

Profile Information

  • Location
    Oxford, MS
  • Interests
    Professional Registered Parliamentarian

Recent Profile Visitors

713 profile views
  1. Annual Meeting Minutes

    Or, appoint a "minutes approval committee" at the annual meeting.
  2. Wait a minute! The question first posed was about joining some members to the meeting electronically. That has nothing to to with absentee voting. It has to do with whether or not electronic meetings are authorized in the bylaws. If they are, then members so joined to a meeting are full participating members in the meeting.
  3. Email motion

    However you want to treat the email vote, your called meeting is a new meeting, and it is in order to make the motion as though it had never been considered before.
  4. Email motion

    Actually, RONR does have a bit to say. It is in the section with the heading "A Vote By Mail," on page 424. the end of the section says, "E-mail and other means of electronic communications can be tailored to comply with these requirements" (RONR pg. 424, ll. 32-33). The point is, this kind of vote, while it can be valid if so authorized in your bylaws, is not a meeting. Therefore, there simply is not yet any motion that has been duly made in the context of a meeting, and one will have to be offered in order for it to come before the assembly.
  5. Voting Website

    In addition to what has been said, I would recommend that you explore the possibility of meeting electronically - which as noted the current edition of RONR indeed contemplates, and I work with numerous organizations that either meet entirely electronically, or meet in person but with one or more members joining electronically. There are a number of considerations when it comes to electronic meetings - some of them technological, some related to bylaws and/or special rules of order. some important considerations are outlined on pages 97-99 of the 11th Edition (the current edition of RONR), and the electronic edition of the 11th edition even includes sample special rules of order for various kinds of electronic meetings.
  6. Minutes

    I think to answer your question fully requires a bit more than saying "no motion, no mention," as my colleague has suggested. If, for example, a committee chair gives an informational report that includes no motions, what the assembly did was listen to a report. So the minutes can say, "Mr. Smith, Chair of the House Committee, reported on the committee's work." What the minutes should not do is attempt to summarize what the chair said.
  7. Treasurers Authority

    It sounds as though you are talking about some sort of vote taken outside of a meeting. The rules in Robert's Rules pertain to voting processes within meetings. If you take votes other than at a meeting, you must look to your own rules for guidance about the requirements.
  8. Youth League Board Member

    Understand that a "term limit" is different from a "term of office." You bylaws should stipulate the length of time for which officers are elected, which is the "term of office," as in: "for a term of two years, or until a successor is elected." A term limit would be something like, "no officer may serve more than three successive terms in the same office." So what do your bylaws say about terms of office? If they say nothing, the result would be that once elected, your officers are elected for life, or until they cease to be eligible (as, for instance, if they are required to be members of the organization to hold office, and they cease to be members). In that case, holding annual elections wouldn't make sense, because you would only need a new one if an old one quit, died, or became ineligible. Assuming your bylaws say that officers are elected for a one year term, then they definitely have to be re-elected each year - and if there is no defined term limit, they may continue to be elected year after year. If your bylaws say something more ambiguous, such as "officers are elected annually" or " . . . at the annual meeting," then that probably means they are elected for one year terms, but that is a matter of interpreting your bylaws, and ultimately, the members of any organization have to interpret their own rules.
  9. Debate Rules

    Unless something in your rules states otherwise, yes, such a motion needs to go to the membership. It is a motion to "limit or extend limit of debate." Since it affects the rights of membership, the motion requires a two thirds vote for adoption.
  10. Club's Code of Ethics

    Unless there is some specific delegation of that authority to the board, then the membership would need to approve it. So it depends on what your bylaws say about the Board's authority.
  11. Debate Rules

    Parliamentarians do not make rulings or "set" rules. They only advise the presiding officer. Nor, for that matter, can the presiding officer make any sort of declaration about rules for debate that alter the default rules of the organization or its parliamentary authority (which, if that authority is Robert's Rules are that each member can speak for up to ten minutes per speech and no more than twice on any motion, the second time only if there aren't others who have not yet spoken). If there are to be other "debate rules," they are adopted under the motion to limit or extend limits of debate. That motion requires a second, is amendable but not debatable, and requires a two thirds vote for adoption.
  12. Chapter representation at a convention

    By its very definition, a convention is "an assembly of delegates" (RONR pg. 600, ll. 2-3), and "delegates are selected by, and from among, the members of each local unit" (RONR pg. 600, ll. 11-12). Unless your rules define your conventions in some other terms, then no, the assembly does not have the authority to seat individuals as delegates who were not properly (in accordance with your rules) "selected by" the local units.
  13. President term limit

    To be clear, unless your rules state otherwise, the VP automatically becomes the President upon a vacancy in the presidency. It doesn't require a vote. My question at this time is, when you last held an election for President, was the President elected for a two year term? And if so, how long ago was that election? It seems to me that if he was elected (correctly or not) for a two year term, then he has the right to serve for that amount of time, and you should correct the problem later - either by holding a special election for a one year term to get you back on track, or by the VP assuming office one year from now.
  14. Votes

    Only if the vote was a "roll call vote," by rule or by order of the body. If the vote was a "counted vote" by rule or by order of the body, then the vote count (for and against) is reported, but not by name.
  15. two Chairs one vote?

    I would add two comments to this conversation First, "it is a fundamental principle of parliamentary law that each person who is a member of a deliberative assembly is entitled to one - and only one - vote on a question" (RONR Pg. 407, ll. 1-4). That said, the question posed is about a committee, which by definition is not a form of deliberative assembly. Second, according to Robert's Rules, in small boards and in committees (regardless of the size), "If the chairman is a member, he may, without leaving the chair, speak in informal discussions and in debate, and vote on all questions" (RONR pg. 488, ll. 18-20).