Committees normally don’t have minutes the way the general membership or a board would, although a committee certainly may do so. Normally, the committee chair makes whatever notes are necessary for the committee’s work. Someone else on the committee may do so, though.
@Richard BrownOur Bylaws do require minutes for all committees.
It is not normally the role of the parliamentarian to “play secretary“ or take minutes and, unless your rules provide to the contrary, he has no business giving directions or orders. The role of the parliamentarian is to advise the chair and the members, not to make rulings. That is the role of the chair, whether it is a committee, board, or general membership meeting. If the committee wants formal minutes, it may elect a secretary for that purpose. If the person responsible for minutes is not properly doing the job, someone else should be selected. As with any other type meeting, if the secretary or person responsible has not prepared minutes, someone else or a committee may be appointed to do so based on the recollection of members as to what was done at that meeting.
@Richard Brown Got it. What could the wording read to elect a secretary for the bylaws committee? We have also had shenanigans happen. For example, the committee voted to move in a direction. A follow up meeting was called 2 weeks later by the Parliamentarian to take action on the same question. The direction approved by the committee was not supported by the President. The membership pushed back and asked for the minutes of the last meeting for reference of the question and vote- no information was provided. Since we have not been given minutes. The Parliamentarian moves at the will of the President.
For what it’s worth, I get the impression that we still are not being given a full picture of what is happening. @Richard Brown😐