the election of sub committee chair person if is required that the nominee leave the room. What happen for get to do that part,is that election out of order

[Guest Joseph B.]

A sub committee chair was elected without following guidelines

[Guest Zev]

I know of no requirement that any nominee leave the room during an election. After all, the nominee himself has a right to cast a vote. You will need to be a little bit more specific as to what exactly are these so-called "guidelines" that were not followed in order to get perhaps a better answer. Are these bylaw restrictions, special rules of order, or just customs that the group follows?

[Joshua Katz]

It sounds as if the answer here will depend upon your rules.

[Guest Joseph B.]

Went nominated , nominee are ask to leave room,so the group can enter discussion about qualification.

[J. J.]

18 minutes ago, Guest Joseph B. said:

Went nominated , nominee are ask to leave room,so the group can enter discussion about qualification.

Does your group actually have a rule that says that? 

[Josh Martin]

1 hour ago, Guest Joseph B. said:

Went nominated , nominee are ask to leave room,so the group can enter discussion about qualification.

• Do your rules actually require that the nominee must leave the room during the election?
• Is the nominee a member of the assembly?

[Gary Novosielski]

7 hours ago, Guest Joseph B. said:

Went nominated , nominee are ask to leave room,so the group can enter discussion about qualification.

On what authority?  Is there any actual rule requiring this?  It's certainly not proper under RONR to exclude a member from discussion.  It occurs to me that the candidate might have something useful to say about his qualifications.