Can one affirmative vote approve 2 issues

[Guest E A Lemoine]

>>Do Robert's Rules allow an affirmative vote on one motion (approval of the budget) to stand for an approval of another issue (how to fund the budget with the special assessment)if it is not specifically made clear in the motion?<<

I"

[Guest Gary c Tesser]

Well.

Point by point (As Mr Lemoine exemplarily did, but differing some):

1. If the special assessments are actually not part of the budget, then adopting the budget does not affect the special assessments (vaguely, RONR 10th Ed, p. 105"

[Guest H.Wm.Mountcastle]

>>I belong to a non-property owners' association<<

Is this for people who don't own property or for people who own non-property?

And is the fact that's it's a man=made lake significant?

I'm afraid I never made it pas"

[Guest Trina]

Although there seem to have been quite a few errors in procedure, none appear to fall into the category of a continuing breach (i.e. an error which still matters after the fact, and for which a point of order can be raised at any time -- see RONR p. 244 f"

[Guest JCB]

The motion was made, not suggested. I made a motion that off-lake members pay $100 and on-lake members pay $125. (Also in first sentence if should have read "non-profit" not "non-property". Sorry to have confused anyone."

[Guest J. J.]

I think the main question would be if your motion violated the bylaws. I may have, and since, we don't have your bylaws (no, don't post them), we can't say.

J. J."

[Guest JCB]

The bylaws only state "Dues and special assessments, other than those specified in the recorded restrictions, may only be assessed upon affirmative vote of the members at an annual or special meeting."

There was a shortfall in the propos"

[Guest John M.]

>>Was there really an affirmative vote on the assessment according to the bylaws?<<

Were the assessments included in the budget? If so, then it would seem so. If not, then no.

>>Was I really out of order when I made the"