write-in votes

[Humane Society member]

Some time ago, I asked if write-in votes were acceptable when voting is by ballot and the bylaws are silent.  I was told write-in votes are 'always permissible when the vote is by ballot'.  There was an election last night, an attorney was in attendance, and the membership was told write-ins would not be accepted.  Needless to say, membership decreased by several.

[George Mervosh]

Some time ago, I asked if write-in votes were acceptable when voting is by ballot and the bylaws are silent.  I was told write-in votes are 'always permissible when the vote is by ballot'.  There was an election last night, an attorney was in attendance, and the membership was told write-ins would not be accepted.  Needless to say, membership decreased by several.

 

Attorneys are allowed to be incorrect when it comes to Robert's Rules.  Did he say why?

[Josh Martin]

Some time ago, I asked if write-in votes were acceptable when voting is by ballot and the bylaws are silent.  I was told write-in votes are 'always permissible when the vote is by ballot'.  There was an election last night, an attorney was in attendance, and the membership was told write-ins would not be accepted.  Needless to say, membership decreased by several.

 

The attorney may have been advising the society regarding a higher-level rule, such as procedural rules in applicable law.