Jump to content
The Official RONR Q & A Forums

George Mervosh

  • Content Count

  • Joined

1 Follower

About George Mervosh

  • Rank
    Professional Registered Parliamentarian

Profile Information

  • Location:
    Pittsburgh PA
  • Interests

Recent Profile Visitors

4,340 profile views
  1. This is not the correct procedure. The board or a committee should be appointed to approve those minutes, but since they were not No. See the rules in RONR (12th ed.), 48:12
  2. I do as well! The NAP Pony Express delivered mine Saturday. Quite a delight to see RONR (12th ed.), 46:27-29 It was worth waiting for the Deluxe Version, I suppose.
  3. Can I ask what your group's parliamentarian thinks about this question, because I'm confused.
  4. Keep voting until someone receives a majority of the votes cast for that position. Nominations can also be re-opened under the rules in RONR if need be.
  5. Anytime a vote is counted on a main motion, I think the count should be announced by the chair and entered into the minutes, yes.
  6. It doesn't appear the motion was ever made.
  7. See Mr. Geiger's post with a link, 2 posts above yours.
  8. The Deluxe Edition takes longer so I might find it under my tree for Christmas.
  9. I think it would be easier to omit all reference to gender in the bylaws and call it a day, since RONR (at the least the 11th edition) doesn't say anything about this.
  10. Yeah, ditch the Iphone and dictation app and enjoy! Yours truly, Bob Mahvash
  11. The citation is from the section on procedures in board meetings. You can kick her out of a meeting if warranted following the procedures noted on pp. 645-49 but that's it. Any further discipline would have to come from the membership of the community.
  12. Suspension will not be an option if these are board meetings unless the bylaws confer additional powers to the board we don't know about. " It may protect itself against breaches of order by its members during board meetings, and against annoyance by nonmembers, by employing the procedures outlined on pages 645–49, but the maximum penalty which may be imposed upon a disorderly member of the board is that he be required to leave the meeting room during the remainder of the meeting." RONR (11th ed.), p. 486 The membership however can impose additional discipline following the proper procedures to do so.
  13. I'm reminded once again of some advice our friend GcT gave someone who was about to chair a meeting and hadn't read either book: "I expect I'm not alone in suggesting emphatically that you first get your RONR - In Brief, without delay, and read it at once. I keep saying, if you go to a store to buy it, read it standing there. Maybe move away from in front of the cashier, to allow the other customers to buy their copies. It should take you an hour or so, unless you're a college graduate -- they can take all day, tomorrow also if they have to tie their shoelaces themselves. If you're on a lunch break, you'll just have to get back a little late. If people are depending on you to feed them -- relax, they won't starve. If you're there by car, give your keys to that cashier, who will be allowed to return them to you when you're finished. If you have ordered it by mail, don't take the time to get a box-cutter to open the carton: just have at it with your fangs and claws -- you're going to chair an AGM, so you need the practice anyway."
  14. What if, at a convention of delegates, it's time to vote for the officers, but the vote will be conducted and tabulated outside of the meeting (quite similar to what NAP has done in the past), and Joe Delegate shows his credential, votes, then immediately drops his credentials off at the desk and leaves the convention for good and is no longer a delegate? Does his vote count even though he's not a member of the convention when the results are announced later in a meeting? I think so, for sure. He was a member when his vote was cast.
  15. In case Mr. Honemann is on the Bay (I hope he is): " In debate, the maker of a motion, while he can vote against it, is not allowed to speak against his own motion." RONR (11th ed.), p. 393 and "Although it is the duty of every member who has an opinion on a question to express it by his vote, he can abstain, since he cannot be compelled to vote. " RONR (11th ed.), p. 407 - note that there is no exception stated for the maker of the motion.
  • Create New...