difference between MM and BB

[Kim Goldsworthy]

If one of the following motions is made ...:

• Take from the table

• Rescind

• Discharge a committee

• Reconsider

... and if there is no second, then,

is the motion to be recorded in the minutes?

[George Mervosh]

all main motions (10) or motions to bring a main question again before the assembly (pp. 72-76; 34-37) - except, normally, any that were withdrawn. p. 452........ Yes, all means all.

[jstackpo]

"Yes, all means all. " - GM

Unless you happen to be talking about the Board filling "all vacancies".

:lol:

[George Mervosh]

"Yes, all means all. " - GM

Unless you happen to be talking about the Board filling "all vacancies".

:lol:

I don't see the two as analogous, but ok

[Kim Goldsworthy]

all main motions (10) or motions to bring a main question again before the assembly (pp. 72-76; 34-37) - except, normally, any that were withdrawn. p. 452........ Yes, all means all.

(excerpt, page 72)

BASIS OF THIS CLASSIFICATION. Four motions are grouped in this book as motions that bring a question again before the assembly since, either by their adoption or by their introduction, they serve the function described by the name of the class.

Q. When unseconded, did any of the four motions bring business before the assembly?

[George Mervosh]

Q. When unseconded, did any of the four motions bring business before the assembly?

You're regurgitating your argument about main motions when unseconded. It doesn't fly then or now. And hasn't the A-Team settled this matter?

[jstackpo]

Certainly. The assembly members were made aware of the business - it was "before" them.

Then the assembly chose to ignore that business.

So now it is behind them, but they properly leave a record, in the minutes, of their desire to do nothing about the business.

[Gary Novosielski]

"Yes, all means all. " - GM

Unless you happen to be talking about the Board filling "all vacancies".

:lol:

All still means all. As soon as a president resigns, the board fills the vacancy that is created. (In the Nth VP position).

[Josh Martin]

If one of the following motions is made ...:

• Take from the table

• Rescind

• Discharge a committee

• Reconsider

... and if there is no second, then,

is the motion to be recorded in the minutes?

Provided the motion is being applied to a "main question" (which is not always the case for the motion to Reconsider), yes.

Q. When unseconded, did any of the four motions bring business before the assembly?

Whether they actually bring business before the assembly is not relevant. They are still motions to bring business before the assembly. They don't suddenly become some other type of motion simply because they were not seconded.